By allowing ads to appear on this site, you support the local businesses who, in turn, support great journalism.
Man accused of shovel slaying indicted by grand jury
Placeholder Image

An Effingham County man accused in the July 4 death of a relative has been indicted on three counts of murder by the grand jury.


Darrell Lovett, 51, of Clyo, also was indicted last month on one count of aggravated battery and two counts of aggravated assault. Authorities allege he struck Arthur Scruggs, 63, several times with a trenching shovel after the two got involved in an argument July 4.


Deputies were called to a house on Sam Smart Road at approximately 8 a.m. on July 4 on the report of an assault. According to Effingham County Sheriff’s reports, deputies found Scruggs inside the house. He was taken to Effingham Hospital, where he was pronounced dead. Reports at the time indicated the two men were related and Scruggs may have been staying temporarily at the house.


An elderly woman who lived at the house passed away from natural causes earlier that morning.


The grand jury also indicted four men in the reported armed robbery and shooting of a pizza deliveryman in August. Peter Johnson III, Joshua Buckner, Curdray Wimberly and a juvenile defendant were indicted on one count each of armed robbery, aggravated assault, theft by receiving stolen property and possession of a firearm in the commission of a felony.


Sheriff’s investigators said a pizza driver was called to a house on Mockingbird Drive in Springfield to deliver three pizzas. But when he got to the house, it was vacant, and there was no car in the driveway. The four suspects then ambushed the pizza driver, according to ECSO reports, and the juvenile fired a .380-caliber handgun at the driver. The bullet went into the boxes containing the pizzas, and the driver suffered minor injuries from shrapnel.


All four suspects were found within hours, each at a different residence.


Grand jurors also indicted Preston Turnbow, Brandon Turnbow and Francis Folgarait on 18 counts of burglary, stemming from the December 2011 break-up of an alleged ring. The three men are accused of forcing their way into homes and taking jewelry and electronics during daylight hours from homes across the county.


An indictment means the grand jury believes there is enough evidence for the case to go to trial.

Volunteers hold 'Demo Party' to help Rincon Woman Rebuild Storm-Damaged Home
Miss Peggy
Matt Evans, owner of Centaur Home Renovations, consults with volunteer Janel Kearney while directing the demolition process. (Mya Taylor / Effingham Herald)

RINCON, Ga. — Volunteers attended a “demo party” over the weekend to help demolish the interior of 82-year-old Miss Peggy’s home, which was left severely damaged by a storm years ago.

A gloomy forecast and threat of rain did not deter the group from working. When the seven volunteers arrived, they were greeted by Centaur Home Renovations owner Matt Evans, who is leading the renovations. Masks, trash bags and tools were handed out as music played from a large speaker and fans helped keep volunteers cool in the summer heat. Orange arrows painted on the walls directed workers to the areas slated for demolition.

Miss Peggy
Leigh Carter strips wallpaper as part of the interior demolition of Miss Peggy’s home during a community ‘demo party’ in Rincon. (Mya Taylor / Effingham Herald)

Leigh Carter, the first to arrive, was one of several who stripped walls and tore out drywall. Carter’s efforts go beyond renovations — she has also driven Miss Peggy to doctor’s appointments and helped her get rehoused last week at Family Promise of Effingham after a brief displacement.

“We want to get Miss Peggy back home in a safe place to live,” Carter said.

Volunteers spread out through the home, removing damaged drywall and hauling debris to a dumpster in the driveway.

“I decided to join because I thought helping somebody would be a good thing to do,” volunteer Sydney Kearney said. “I just thought it would be nice to volunteer.”

Miss Peggy
Grayson Heaton uses a crowbar to help remove damaged walls during the volunteer demolition day. (Mya Taylor / Effingham Herald)

Repairs underway
Michael’s Roofing of Meldrim completed the first major repair by rebuilding and installing a new roof. The previous roof had been damaged by a fallen tree, which led to water leaks, mildew and mold spreading through the home.

Now Evans and Centaur Home Renovations are leading the next phase of work. Evans joined volunteers in the demolition and said community support has been growing since news of Miss Peggy’s situation was first reported in the Effingham Herald. 

“Since the article was first published, we’ve gotten quite a few reach-outs from people willing to donate their time,” Evans said. “We’ve also had four different dumpster companies donate dumpsters for the cause as well.”

Community organizations are also pitching in. Family Promise and the Manna House Food Pantry and Thrift Store have pledged to provide furniture and other materials once renovations are complete.

The most recent setback came when the septic tank lids collapsed, causing the system to stop working. Evans said crews are now cleaning the tank and clearing the lines.

Miss Peggy
Benny Carter tosses an old mattress into a dumpster as part of cleanup efforts at Miss Peggy’s storm-damaged home. (Mya Taylor / Effingham Herald)

What’s still needed
“After the demo is completed, we can start looking for more materials we’ll need like lumber, drywall, paint, flooring and more to get the house back together,” Evans said.

Additional materials still needed include:

  • 25 2x4x8 studs

  • Four sheets of OSB sheathing

  • Twenty 12-foot deck boards (5/4)

  • Twelve 12-foot sheets of sheetrock

  • 36-inch vanity

  • Two toilets

  • Four ceiling fans

  • Two bathroom fans

  • 60-inch vanity

  • 60-inch fiberglass tub and surround

  • 60-inch fiberglass shower and surround

  • 1,600 square feet of LVP flooring

  • 36-inch exterior door

  • Rolls of drywall tape

  • Buckets of drywall mud

  • Bags of 20-minute drywall joint compound

  • 100 linear feet of baseboard and quarter round

  • 10 gallons of Kilz or Cover Stain

  • 10–12 gallons of white paint

There is no estimated timeline for completion, as more funds and supplies are needed. The GoFundMe campaign for Miss Peggy’s home renovations has raised more than $1,400.

Donations can be made at gofundme.com/f/help-ms-peggy-return-to-a-safe-home.

Miss Peggy
The interior of Miss Peggy’s home shows ceiling stripped and debris cleared in preparation for renovations. (Mya Taylor / Effingham Herald)