By allowing ads to appear on this site, you support the local businesses who, in turn, support great journalism.
GOP hopefuls tout energy independence
06.01 GOP forum
Congressional candidate John Stone, right, thanks the Savannah Young Republicans as opponents Ben Crystal, left, and Ray McKinney applaud. The Savannah Young Republicans held a forum Thursday night for the 12th District GOP candidates. - photo by Photo by Pat Donahue

GOP forum-John Stone

John Stone at the GOP 12th District forum

To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video

GOP forum-Ray McKinney

Ray McKinney at the 12th District GOP forum

To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video

GOP forum-Ben Crystal

Ben Crystal at the 12th District Republican forum

To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video

SAVANNAH — GOP hopefuls for the 12th District Congressional seat agree on at least one thing — there isn’t enough being done to allow for exploration of oil and gas resources within the U.S.

Republican candidates for the seat currently held by Savannah Democrat John Barrow Ben Crystal, Ray McKinney and John Stone said they would push for long-term approaches involving greater offshore drilling and opening the Alaska National Wildlife Refuge. But their short-range solutions differ.

Crystal, a former Savannah talk radio host, said there are 2.1 trillion barrels of oil captured in the oil shale deposits in Wyoming, Utah and Colorado.

“We don’t touch it. It’s ours,” he said. “The world’s current oil petroleum reserves are 1.317 billion (barrels). We’re not talking about an energy independence being available in our Western states; we’re talking about a true American energy domination. It’s our oil and we don’t touch it because our government has said forget about it.

Crystal laid the blame at Greenpeace and the Earth Liberation Front for blocking the exploration of the oil shale reserves.

“We’ll take it back,” he said. “Anwar is nothing compared to our oil shale.”

Crystal also lamented that China has drilling rights in the Gulf of Mexico, but the U.S. is restricting how much exploration can be done there. He also said that no matter how much more oil is pumped and put into the market, it won’t be the only step.

“If our refinery capacity hasn’t expanded, it won’t matter,” he said.

McKinney said in the short term, the nation can build the current supply by suspending the addition of oil into the national strategic reserve by putting its oil royalties on the open market.

“But that’s a quick fix,” he said.

What’s also hurt has been the weak U.S. dollar. Its decreasing value has helped drive oil prices skyward.

“Being fiscally responsible will bring the value of the dollar back up,” McKinney said.

Stone has called for a suspension of federal and state fuel taxes to bring the cost at the pump down and wants to remove the tariff on import ethanol.

“It’s devastating,” Stone said of the fuel prices. “If we don’t do something immediately, it’s going to drive us into a recession.”

The House Republican Caucus voted earlier this week to repeal the 18.5 cent per gallon federal tax, but that move faces an uncertain future on Capitol Hill.

Stone also wants to end the tax subsidies to oil companies, which he said run to almost $17 billion, and put that money in the federal highway trust fund instead to offset the loss of gas tax revenues.

Stone, a staffer for former U.S. Rep. Max Burns, said the Republican-controlled House approved the exploration and drilling the three candidates support now.

“In 1995, the new Republican House voted to allow drilling in ANWR, allow drilling offshore and build new refineries, and it was all vetoed by Bill Clinton,” he said.

Stone also evoked the name of Democratic President John F. Kennedy and his 1962 challenge to put a man on the moon in 10 years.

“We need to commit to energy independence in 10 years,” he said. “We need to expand hydro power and expand the use of clean-burning coal. We need to make the Department of Energy the NASA of the 21st century.”

But his competitors chastised his stance on the oil company subsidies because of the difference between profits and profit margins.

“Last year, the oil companies paid $138 billion in taxes,” McKinney said. “The American people paid $130 billion. Right now, Russia is coming up with tax breaks for their oil companies to find more oil.”

Said Crystal: “Microsoft made more than ExxonMobil last year.”

Crystal also said that little venom has been directed at CITGO, the Venezuelan national oil company, but the four major U.S. oil companies have been targets of criticism.

“It’s easy to pick on our guys,” he said.

Stone said he wasn’t suggesting a tax increase on American oil companies.

“Our working folks need that tax cut more than the oil companies do,” he said. “I support a free market as a Republican. But when you have four companies controlling the oil in the U.S., that’s not a free market.”

Crystal and McKinney also made the call for a wider use of nuclear power.

“We haven’t built a new reactor in 30 years,” Crystal said.

McKinney said the U.S. has lost the technology to do that kind of work.

“We have over 100 operating units in this country, and we can no longer build one,”  he said. “With 23 years of experience in the energy field, I know what this country can do and I know what the holdups are.”

All three espoused free trade and fair trade and dismissed the notions that the Republicans face an even bleaker future in the 2008 elections than they did in the 2006 vote.

“We live in a world where on a daily basis we are reminded of government’s failures,” Crystal said. “We are a party of true change. The greatest moments that have occurred in the nation’s history have been led on by the Grand Old Party, the party of Lincoln, the party of civil rights, the party of Ronald Reagan, the party that says the global war on terror must be won and decisively, not incrementally.”

McKinney said when Hillary Clinton remarked that the Republican Party had forgotten the middle class, he was spurred to action.

Stone said a Republican candidate can win back the seat that Barrow first won from Burns in 2004.

“This is a golden year for Republicans in this district,” he said. “We can win this seat back, and we can win our party back from the people on Wall Street who hijacked it.”

Stone said that while Republicans are quick to cast Democrats as the tax and spend party, the GOP leadership has let the nation down.

“Once we had all three branches of government, the Republicans became the party of just plain spend,” Stone said.

“And that’s absolutely intolerable.

“We need to put our Republican Party back on the right course, because it’s been hijacked by Wall Street.”

Though the 12th District stretches from western Chatham up the Savannah River valley to Augusta and Taliaferro County, Stone said there is a lot in common for its residents.

“Our district is historic, colonial Georgia,” he said. “We have historic, cultural and economic ties unlike any Congressional district I’ve ever seen. We are original Georgia.”

Effingham County Ends 80-Year Partnership with Live Oak Libraries
Plans to Start Independent Library System; Library Board Chair Erica Biezenbos Removed
Live Oak Public Libraries
Live Oak Public Libraries attorney Wade Herring addresses Effingham County commissioners during Tuesday’s nearly two-hour hearing on both the removal of Library Board Chair Erica Biezenbos and the county’s decision to split from Live Oak, as a capacity crowd of supporters fills the room. (Mya Taylor / Effingham Herald)

SPRINGFIELD, Ga. — After a rowdy, more than two-hour public hearing Tuesday night, Effingham County commissioners voted unanimously to end the county’s more than 80-year partnership with the Live Oak Public Libraries system and to remove Library Board Chair Erica Biezenbos.

Commissioners plan to establish a new,  county library system.

The audience — made up almost entirely of Live Oak supporters — erupted in boos as commissioners cast their votes, finalizing a decision that will fundamentally reshape the future of local library services. No member of the public spoke in favor of ending the partnership.

The vote ends Effingham’s decades-long affiliation with the Savannah-based regional library system, which oversees branches in Rincon and Springfield. The split will not take effect until June 30, 2026.

“It’s a nine-month process,” County Manager Tim Callanan said after the meeting.

Financial review and county rationale

The decision followed months of review into the county’s financial and administrative relationship with Live Oak. The county recently completed a detailed review, led by retired school librarian and media specialist Nate Ball and retired CPA Wesley Corbitt. Their analysis found that Effingham’s library funding is significantly higher than comparable counties, largely because of administrative overhead. County officials said the change will allow Effingham to reduce administrative costs, gain greater local control, and reinvest savings into staff, programs, and facilities.

“This is about finances,” commission chairman Damon Rahn said.

Critics warned that leaving Live Oak could cost the county access to a large portion of its physical collection and specialized programs, including literacy resources, early childhood initiatives, and partnerships with Savannah-area museums.

More than a dozen Live Oak supporters challenged the accuracy of Ball’s and Corbitt’s audit and expressed concern about potential censorship. They urged commissioners to postpone the vote until a full financial and transition plan could be presented to the public.

“You need to take a minute and give the community time to process,” one supporter said. Commenters also expressed concern about the impact on low-income residents, seniors, and other members of the community who regularly rely on the library. 

Live Oak supporters also accused commissioners of back-room dealing, claiming that Ball — a former grade school media specialist hired under a consulting contract approved in December 2024 — was promised the library director position with a proposed salary of $120,000.

The public hearing grew heated at times, with residents frustrated over both the process and the potential impact on the county’s two library branches. At one point, Rahn had to warn audience member Ivy Gibbins to stop interrupting or she would be removed.

Ball’s and Corbitt’s audit indicated the county could save up to $373,000 annually by operating its own system. Consultants assured commissioners that core statewide resources — including PINES (the statewide library lending network) and GALILEO (Georgia’s virtual library system) — would remain available under any new arrangement.

Live Oak Public Libraries
Erica Biezenbos answers questions from the county’s attorney, Edward Newberry, during Tuesday’s hearing on her removal as Effingham County Library Board Chair. (Mya Taylor / Effingham Herald)

Commissioners pledge reinvestment

County commissioners promised that the libraries would not close and that, according to the agreement with Live Oak, resources and staff would remain available in each branch. They emphasized that the $373,000 in projected savings would be reinvested into library operations.

“We want to reinvest in our board and libraries,” Commissioner Roger Burdette said. Burdette, who in 2023 expressed concerns about LGBTQ-themed materials in Effingham libraries, sought to address fears that he intended to censor library content.

“Why would I wait more than a year,” he said, “if that was my plan?”

He added: “No one wants to get rid of library services.”

Commissioner Jamie DeLoach said, “I want to keep Effingham dollars in Effingham County. Reinvest the money in our services and people.”

Commissioner Beth Helmly praised the passion of Live Oak supporters. “We can make a good library system ourselves. Many of you say we can’t do it without Live Oak. I say we can,” she said.

The commission also voted unanimously to remove Biezenbos as library board chair and replace her with Sherry Duff, citing repeated procedural and oversight failures.

Attorney Wade Herring, who represented Biezenbos and Live Oak during the hearing, argued that commissioners could not remove Biezenbos without due process. The county’s lawyer, Edward Newberry, said the county’s bylaws give commissioners the legal authority to remove her.

New allegations surface ahead of vote

On Monday, the day before the public hearing, a new letter alleged that top county officials orchestrated a plan to separate the libraries without proper legal authority or public transparency. The claims added to the debate surrounding the county’s long-standing partnership with Live Oak and fueled criticism from supporters of the regional system.

If you missed Tuesday’s meeting, you can watch the full proceedings on the county’s YouTube channel.